Both Garmin and Fitbit offer comprehensive sleep tracking, but Garmin excels for serious athletes with its Body Battery feature, while Fitbit provides a more user-friendly experience for general wellness.
The Verdict
Choose Garmin if you're an endurance athlete who wants detailed training metrics alongside sleep. Choose Fitbit if you want simple, accessible sleep tracking with a user-friendly interface.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Garmin | Fitbit |
|---|---|---|
| Sleep Stage Accuracy | Good | Good |
| Battery Life | Excellent (weeks)✓ | Good (5-6 days) |
| Energy/Recovery Score | Body Battery (excellent)✓ | Daily Readiness |
| App User-Friendliness | Complex | Very easy✓ |
| Smart Wake Alarm | Yes | Yes |
| Subscription Required | No✓ | Yes for full features |
| GPS/Workout Features | Excellent✓ | Good |
| Price Range | $300-1000 | $150-300✓ |
Garmin
Pros
- Exceptional battery life (weeks)
- Body Battery shows energy levels
- No subscription needed
- Best-in-class GPS and fitness
- Very durable/rugged
Cons
- Interface can be overwhelming
- Higher price point
- Sleep tracking less refined than dedicated trackers
- App has learning curve
Fitbit
Pros
- Most user-friendly interface
- More affordable
- Good community features
- Simple sleep score
- Accessible for beginners
Cons
- Premium subscription for full features
- Shorter battery life
- Being integrated into Google ecosystem
- Less robust fitness features
Who Should Choose What
Choose Garmin if:
Runners, cyclists, and outdoor athletes who want comprehensive training data with sleep insights
Choose Fitbit if:
Casual fitness enthusiasts and beginners who want simple, accessible sleep and activity tracking
Pricing Comparison
Garmin
$300-1000 device, no subscription
Fitbit
$150-300 device + $10/month Premium optional
More Comparisons
Whoop vs Oura Ring
Both Whoop and Oura Ring are top-tier sleep trackers favored by biohackers and a...
Whoop vs Apple Watch
Whoop is a dedicated fitness and recovery tracker while Apple Watch is an all-pu...
Oura Ring vs Apple Watch
Oura Ring offers dedicated health tracking in a discrete ring form factor, while...